Advertisements

This Just In: Budget Travel's Blog

You can always trust us—because we never take freebies or accept any travel discounts.
Recent Posts
  • All Recent Posts
People Are Talking…
Affordable Paris
Seine River at sunset
A special series of posts delivering money-saving travel tips.
Popular Authors
Sean O'Neill
Blog Editor
View author page
Kate Appleton
Editor Online
View author page
Brad Tuttle
Contributing Editor
View author page
AddThis Feed Button
Prove you're not a terrorist
Posted by: Sean O'Neill, Monday, Apr 16, 2007, 3:59 PM

Today, Wired posted a story about the travelers' watch lists kept by various governmental agencies and airlines. The story highlights cases of mistaken identities between legitimate and illegitimate travelers.

The article highlights the story of Princeton professor Walter Murphy, "one of the nation's most respected constitutional law professors," who was put on a watch list--even though he is not a threat to the U.S.

Here's the good news: In February, the Department of Homeland Security set up a new webpage that allows people to "resolve possible watch list misidentification issues." But the process isn't as effective as many people would like it...

It's unnerving to be pulled aside by passport control officials, as I can say from personal experience....

My name comes up on at least one of the U.S. government watch lists. It seems that my name and birth-date are shared by someone on a watch list who is alarming to U.S. officials. Whenever I return from a trip overseas, I'm taken aside by passport control officials.

The delays can be inconvenient. My most recent visit with passport control officers lasted more than 80 minutes. Now if an 80-minute per trip delay were the price of liberty, I'd accept it quietly. But I bet that my predicament is due to a bureaucratic snafu that could be quickly resolved. And, as Wired's article points out, thousands of people appear to be wrongly identified as potential threats.

One of the travelers quoted in Wired's article says, "It was unnerving sitting in that little room even for a short period of time. You get a sense of what people who are not senators and not citizens go through."

How true. When I was pulled into a passport control office this past February at J.F.K. airport, I wasn't the only guy there. One of the other travelers was an elderly man who spoke a foreign language that none of the officials in the room spoke. One of the officials joked that they'd have to detain him indefinitely, and the others laughed. The elderly man may not have spoken English, but he knew they were laughing at him.

Reader Comments

hooray for treating our visitors well!
DHS does a Great job showing people their first glimpse of America... NOT!

Too bad DHS doesn't understand that we enhance our security in the long-run by taking the moral high ground in the short-run. Never mind that it's much better for our economy to have tourists not think of the US as a place where foreigners are treated poorly at the borders...

Posted By omars on January 5, 2009, 12:05 AM

I was expecting Homeland Security when I visited USA a couple of years ago.

USA - Land of the free. Free FBI files for everyone, that is. They take a Mugshot, and fingerprint every single person visiting the country. I knew about it, and I decided that my brother's wedding was worth sacrificing my privacy. I can tell you now though that I wouldn't have been interested in this process as a casual tourist. I have no idea how much it hurts US tourism, but I suspect I'm not the only one who isn't interested in this kind of privacy invasion out of hand.

Interestingly, during my visit to the USA, I went for a day-trip over the border to Tijuana. When I came back over the border from Mexico, the Customs official glanced at my passport and the green piece of cardboard in it (issued to visitors from friendly nations, we don't need full visas). He asked "You from down under?" I replied in the affirmative, and explained that I had just been in Tijuana for a day trip. He passed me through into the USA without even taking my passport out of it's little wallet. Didn't open it or anything.

Good times in the USA. :)

Posted By Nathan on January 7, 2009, 4:31 AM

Leave a Comment


(This is a moderated blog. Your comment will need to be approved by the site owner before it will appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)


We encourage users to analyze, comment on, and even challenge the articles, blogs, reviews, and multimedia features of BudgetTravel.com.

User reviews and comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies or any other policies governing this site. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions.