This Just In: Budget Travel's Blog

You can always trust us—because we never take freebies or accept any travel discounts.
Recent Posts
  • All Recent Posts
People Are Talking…
Popular Authors
Sean O'Neill
Contributing Editor
View author page
Brad Tuttle
Contributing Editor
View author page
Andrea Minarcek
Senior Editor
View author page
AddThis Feed Button
There is no "holiday travel fee," no matter what you've heard
Posted by: Sean O'Neill, Saturday, Sep 26, 2009, 6:51 PM

Some news organizations are saying that airlines are going to charge a fee for traveling on the most popular travel days this winter.

Pay no attention.

The airlines aren't charging "a holiday travel fee." If they did, they would violate federal regulations. An airline isn't allowed to offer a fare for $500 and then, when you book it, surprise you and say, "Gotcha! Because you're traveling on Sunday November 29, you have to pay an extra $10 each way." In other words, an airline can't slap on a fee for traveling on a particular day the same way it charges a fee for checking a bag or upgrading your seat.

So what are reporters and bloggers squawking about?

Several days ago, American Airlines added a "miscellaneous surcharge" of $10 each way for domestic flights on the Sunday following Thanksgiving and on the weekend of Jan. 2-3, 2010. In other words, American began including in its base fare a surcharge that's just like a fuel surcharge. When American advertises its fares for holiday travel, the fares you see in newspaper advertisements or on travel websites will already include this surcharge.

United, US Airways, and Delta (plus its Northwest division) added the surcharge, too.

UPDATE Oct. 6
: This fee has spread to 10 days total during the holidays, reports The Motley Fool. (Nov. 30, Dec. 19, Dec. 26, Dec. 27, March 14, 20, 21, 28, April 11, and May 28.)

They might as well just have raised their fares as they usually do: Same difference to you. All you need to know is that airfares will be higher during the holidays this year than they were last year. The reason is simple: More people will be traveling but there will be fewer planes to carry them as the airlines try to regain profitability.

Why did airlines invent this confusing surcharge in the first place?

The simple answer: A surcharge is a lazy way to make sure airlines rake in big bucks this year. It's easier to slap a $10 surcharge onto every ticket than doing the complex calculations needed to raise prices by various amounts on thousands of routes ($8 more on one route, $18 on another, and so forth).

Rick Seaney at airline ticket comparison website FareCompare.com broke the news of this novel accounting maneuver. But when he used the phrase "Holiday travel fee" in the headline of his blog post, he confused some reporters, who then spread the confusion further. I wish he had spelled out in a clear sentence or two that This Is Not the Same Thing As a Baggage Fee.

Kudos to Kelly Yamanouchi of the Atlanta Journal Constitution for being one of the only reporters to point out this important nuance. A surcharge is something you have to pay whether you want to or not. A fee is something you can say no to.

On a side note: If I was a ticket-pricing analyst for an airline, I might be insulted. Or worried about keeping my high salary. The CEOs of the airlines just told me to take a flying leap. Airline execs seem to be betting that they'll net more money by slapping on a flat surcharge on every ticket more reliably by using fancy software to calculate thousands of different fare changes.

I predict that one day airline CEOs will act like Shakespeare's Henry VI. Instead of saying, "Let's kill all the lawyers," they'll say "Let's fire all of the pricing analysts."

Maybe they'll switch to an eBay model (or Google AdWords model), letting passengers bid for airfares in a rapid-fire way. They may say, how much would you be willing to pay to fly from Denver to Omaha on November 28th at 7 p.m., between a range of $300 and $800. And you could say what the lowest price is you'd hope to pay and what the maximum price is you'd like to pay, and then the computers would either accept or match your bid--sort of like Priceline, only you'd know exactly what flight and airline you're bidding to fly on.

Okay, maybe that's fantastical. Airlines can't be that innovative.

But fees and surcharges are here to stay, for sure. And prices aren't likely to drop between now and the holidays, so book as you soon as you can.

EARLIER
New seat-selection fee on British Airways

Reader Comments

So it's not a holiday travel fee, it's a holiday travel surcharge. Thanks for clearing up that media misinformation in your informative column. The public will doubtless find it very useful in saving money.

Posted By Bradley J. Fikes on September 26, 2009, 8:48 PM

Thanks a lot for the very helpful post. I'd be sure to pass this along to my readers.

Posted By Jet Set Life on September 26, 2009, 10:30 PM

The "saving money advice" was to book your tickets early. Procrastinators will pay dearly, unless the economy dips again.
There's nothing you can do to avoid paying a surcharge, I'm afraid. Unlike a fee, you can't avoid it.
--Sean

Posted By Sean on September 26, 2009, 11:25 PM

Hi Sean,
I saw your post and just to be clear added the following to my blog post.

“The surcharge is a rule category associated with a given airfare and is added on to the base fare and taxed (the actual surcharge is $9.30 + the 7.5% tax, equaling to $10). When you look at online price quotes it will be baked into based price of the airfare (not something charged separately like pre-paid checked bag fees).”

I have also attached the release that went to reporters on Thursday night (from our CTO as I was in-flight) and on Friday (we didn’t notice it was coded as Q (Miscellaneous) until after that initial release went out, typically it is coded F which is Fuel Surcharge).

The Fee mention in the blog post was rhetorical and was posted well after the reporters got these releases so I do not believe they were mis-informed. I believe the post is pretty clear on what was filed as it goes into a somewhat inside baseball discussion.

Cheers,
Rick
http://rickseaney.com/2009/09/25/holiday-travel-fee-under-guise-of-flight-fuel-surcharge/

Posted By Rick Seaney on September 27, 2009, 10:55 AM

I believe Bradley's point is that you are splitting hairs. We, the flying public, do not care if it is called a surcharge or a fee.

Posted By Nunya on September 28, 2009, 12:16 AM

Thanks for commenting, Nunya. I'm sure you're not alone in your opinion. And I certainly don't want to split hairs. That would make for a boring blog post.

Here's what I was trying to say: While the airlines can charge fees for everything from seat selection to checked bags, the Feds won't allow them to charge a special fee for flying on a particular date--meaning they can't advertise one fee and then charge you a higher price specifically because of your date of travel.

A year ago, that would have been splitting hairs, for sure. But the airlines have been on a "fee for all" lately, and I found it reassuring that there some kinds of fees that the airlines can't charge.

Thanks again.

Posted By Sean on September 28, 2009, 9:08 AM

Oh, please. Sean, what crap. The bottom line is travelers on those particular dates have to pay more -- simply for flying on those days.

Your headline of "there's no 'holiday travel fee'" may be TECHNICALLY correct, but for a traveler, it's full of bull. He/she is paying extra, no matter what it's called.

Posted By Kokuanani on October 8, 2009, 5:08 PM

Leave a Comment





We encourage users to analyze, comment on, and even challenge the articles, blogs, reviews, and multimedia features of BudgetTravel.com.

User reviews and comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate comments or material will be removed from the site. Additionally, entries that are unsigned or contain "signatures" by someone other than the actual author will be removed. Finally, we will take steps to block users who violate any of our posting standards, terms of use or privacy policies or any other policies governing this site. Please review the full rules governing commentaries and discussions.

Follow Us!

Booking Tool

Check Current Prices

  1. Hotels
  2. Flights
  3. Cars
  4. Cruises

Choose Sites

Choose Sites

Choose Sites

Choose Sites

Get Custom Content

Select the details relevant to your trip to see a list of articles that match your needs — it's the best way to get ideas!
SELECT YOUR DESTINATION
SELECT YOUR ACTIVITIES